Pages

Friday, May 4, 2012

The Saved and The Damned

The Damned
Luca Signorelli
Duomo, Orvieto


On Thu, May 3, 2012 at 12:53 PM, FO wrote:

The Israelites are still out in the wilderness of Sinai. Korah rebelled against Moses and the earth opened up and swallowed him whole and all his followers and they went down to Sheol.  ---

Whoah!  I think this can happen, but not very often. It's what I saw when I spent time with dying patients at the hospital  -- they all went to heaven, except for two fellows -- I remember this very clearly -- these two fellows dying would not let go of their anger, they were cursing and they were headed for darkness and I remember looking at them and wanting to say -- "it's not too late, let it go, rise up to the light that's coming" -- but I think these two fellows went to hell, except I wasn't present at the very end, so they have may repented.

Anyway, the best I can come up with is that Korah and a few other people go to hell, but most of us are going to heaven.

How does it look to you?

--
FO


Dear F,

I remember your God-damned patients.

And yes, I think most of us are going to "heaven." (Have you heard "the dirty little secret?" About 15% of near-death experiences are hellish.)

My hunch is that everyone "gets in" though often there will be hell to pay. 

Tell me.

Were you as disappointed as I when Rome deconstructed purgatory?

Earth Is Purgatory. (Some suggest Earth is the hell of another planet, but they are wrong. Earth is purgatory. If, when we die, we are not ready to gaze peaceably on The Beatific Vision, we go to purgatory.)

Whether we reach heaven after a single "round" of terrestrial purgatory (or if our liberation requires a others) people eventually undergo metanoia. (Even Republicans will one day sign off on tax hikes despite the solemn oaths they've spoken before man and God.)

And if some people prove irremediably obtuse, I venture their souls are snuffed from existence altogether. 

And if they are not "extinguished," then would a loving God not "sedate" them like Lord Rhoop in The Voyage of the Dawn Treader - perpetual nightmare giving way to "sleep without dreams."

"Eternal" punishment -- even self-induced "eternal" punishment -- would serve no purpose consistent with The Nature of Love - at least assuming Love is bound with compassion. 

I do not believe Love would - or could - structure existence in such a damnable way. 

Even we humans, bloodthirsty and vengeful as we are, do not design endless torment whether directly, or indirectly. Even those military and para-miliatry fiends who torture their fellows, send them to their cells for gruel and sleep.

Should we not hope God is at least as "good?"

And what are we worshiping otherwise?

Speaking of damnation, I increasingly marvel at the widespread "Christian" notion that Love need not participate in Compassion.

This bizarre bifurcation seems an attempt to "use" Love for self-centered satisfaction, making sure the dog can always be kicked. 

Consider the following parade of "Good Christians" and those who applaud brutality. 

Republicans Cheer the Death of Uninsured Americans - Ron Paul:  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=irx_QXsJiao

Rick Perry Applauded for Record Number of Executions: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ixMvyaZmcoQ

Herman Cain Calling for the Electrocution of Mexicans: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jO-q5lI7618

If there is room in heaven for such as these, there is room for everyone. And so I hope.

From "God's point of view," the "strategic advantage" of representing Hell as endless is that every soul must be liberated at some particular junction. 

Why not then "load the dice," focusing people on The Great Gift of this incarnation - the one they  have in hand now. 

If not now, when?) 

If "Accepting The Gift" -- which is to say "Accepting Grace" -- is essential to "salvation," what are we to make of the endless litany of sour grape grievance expressed by the American "Right?"

American "conservatives" are such fearful people that they devote their lives to the propagation of fear. 

It is, I believe, their fondness for fear that disposes them to applaud visions of interminable Hell.

Not one in bizillion "conservatives" measures up to 1 John 4:18 - "There is no fear in love. But perfect love drives out fear, because fear has to do with punishment." http://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=1+John+4%3A18&version=NIV

Fear has to do with punishment. 

There is no fear in love. 

Yes, there are things to fear in this world. 

But humor must hold the upper hand. (Not surprisingly, the really funny people are left-of-center. Rev. William Sloan Coffin got it right when he said: "The heart leans to the left.")

At minimum, it is every Christian's obligation to refrain from propagating fear beyond reasonable bound, even if staying within reasonable bound welcomes martyrdom.

With virtual unanimity modern Christians are quicker to kill than to lay down their lives.

Where is "literalism" when needed most?  

“You have heard that it was said, ‘Love your neighbor[a] and hate your enemy.’  But I tell you, love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you,  that you may be children of your Father in heaven. He causes his sun to rise on the evil and the good, and sends rain on the righteous and the unrighteous.  If you love those who love you, what reward will you get? Are not even the tax collectors doing that?  And if you greet only your own people, what are you doing more than others? Do not even pagans do that?  Be complete, therefore, as your heavenly Father is complete." Matthew 5:43-48


Shifting gears...

Increasingly, I see salvation-or-damnation-in-the-afterlife as a distraction. 

Obsessed by individual fate, we labor within the confines of our own souls, pursuing the personal trappings of "salvation," forgetting that "the kingdom of God is among us" even more, I think, than within us. 

Thus distracted, we isolate ourselves in pursuit of "heavenly" self-interest and on that egotistical course renounce "the general welfare" of humankind. 

I think God would not be happy.

Dickens nailed it: 

"But you were always a good man of business, Jacob," faltered Scrooge...  

"Business!" cried the Ghost, wringing its hands again.  "Mankind was my business.  The common welfare was my business; charity, mercy, forbearance, and benevolence, were, all, my business.  The dealings of my trade were but a drop of water in the comprehensive ocean of my business!" http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YGGohTPuOeQ     

As Marley discovered, so too is America's "trade but a drop of water in the comprehensive ocean of our business." 

Will we wake from this self-imposed nightmare - deliberately devised, long labored and at last exported? 

Will we, at minimum, have courage to confess our reward? The reward of business? The reward of Mammon? The reward of The Golden Calf?  http://www.stormfax.com/1dickens.htm

 "I tell you the truth," said the Nazarene. "They have received their reward in full." 

We are burdened by busyness, much of it the busyness of seeking our own salvation.

Against this graspingness, Judaism's demotion of the afterlife is a useful antidote. Without the perpetual anxiety surrounding "Salvation!" -- and the sirenic distraction, "Will I make the cut?" -- Jews focus their lived lives and delighting in the gift that IS -- and their responsiveness to it -- as their primary obligation.

L'Chaim!

In the Old Testament, when God first identifies "himself," "he" declares (as if "speaking" Being into Being) "I am who am." 

Was there ever such a sentence?  The verb "be" used twice in four word span.

Given that God dwells here-and-now Judaism wisely focuses what is this moment, The Eternal Present. (My sister Janet has a priest friend who says - and I paraphrase - 'Heaven has begun. And when we die it will only deepen.")

In pursuit of salvation, we Christians drive ourselves to distraction, fretful, fidgeting and afraid. (Ironically, the Siamese qualities most likely to obstruct salvation are fretfulness and fear.)

By fixating The Grand Prize of heavenly afterlife, our left hand knows all too well what the right is doing. And so haunted we distance ourselves from God's dwelling among us.

Recently, Janet and I were discussing our Catholic upbringing, and how it was clear to us (in the 1950s) that monks resided at the "heart of things" and that the administrative hierarchy was a utilitarian superstructure that discharged crucial functions but was not "the juice."

In closing, I will address my most recent epiphany.

The range of Christian belief is so vast -- the Amish at one end subscribing to absolute pacifism and bible-bangers at the other eagerly anticipating "the next war." 

Given this diversity - given that one sect's credo is another curse - what, in God's name, makes us think our tiny slice of the religious spectrum is The One and Only Truth?

I do not say this in contempt of well-defined positions. "Purpose" is a marvelous quality just as the purpose of Mormon family life rescues that religion from the vain megalomania of its sexually-abusive prophet. http://paxonbothhouses.blogspot.com/2012/04/romney-mormonism-and-christianity.html

Rather, I criticize self-certainty to defend the Magnum Mysterium in whose unfathomable depths humility takes root. However awkwardly I inhabit the outskirts of humility, it tell me this: "Southern Baptists have a point. Methodists have a point. Presbyterians have a point. Lutherans have a point. Anglicans have a point. Episcopalians have a point. Store-front black churches have a point. Rev. Fred Phelps has a point. Apocalypse Cheerleaders have a point. Quakers have a point. The Pope has a point. Holy Rollers have a point. Shakers have a point. Anabaptists have a point. Catholic Workers have a point. Jesuits have a point. Paulists have a point. Benedictines have a point. Trappists have a point. Franciscans have a point. Dominicans have a point. The Servants of the Paraclete have a point. The Desert Fathers have a point. Catholic nuns have a point. Mother Teresa has a point. Mercy Sisters have a point. The Sisters of St. Joseph have a point. Liberation theology has a point. Mega-churches have a point.  Mormonism has a point.  Mahayana Buddhism has a point. Hinayana Buddhism has a point. Zen has a point. Taoism has a point. Jainism has a point. Hinduism has many points. Orthodox Judaism has a point. Reformed Judaism has a point. Zionism has a point. Bahai has a point. Islam has a point. Sufism has a point.'

The litany ambles on making it ever more clear that reverence for The Mystery -- the insoluble Mystery -- sounds the only cautionary note that can prevent us from using our self-certain individual "points" to burst every balloon but our own. (Ever notice that "The Bible Belt" is a weapon - used buckle end first?)

I would surrender my earthly fortune if every Christian were to read "Amish Grace: How Forgiveness Transcended Tragedy." http://www.amazon.com/Amish-Grace-Forgiveness-Transcended-Tragedy/dp/0787997617

I am not a pacifist, but I openly confess that Amish pacifism shames me. 

Standing in the brilliance of "Amish light" -- with its pacifism and forgiveness and determination to love their enemies (if indeed that is how they see them) -- my darkness is defined and I am shamed by my self. 

In comparison, other "Christians" -- myself included -- are petty minions of Satan living our manipulated lives, pretending that God Almighty wants us to bomb Vietnam back to The Stone Age; that God wants us to slaughter countless Iraqis as fit retribution for 9/11; and now God wants us to invade Iran because -- of course! -- the Mahdi is about to return and those diabolical mullahs will forsake all human restraint.

The Amish put their lives where their beliefs are.

The rest of us put somebody else's life where our zoological belligerence is.

If one heeds only the words Yeshua himself spoke, it is obvious to me that the Amish are servants of The Good News and that "the rest of us" -- despite noble moments -- are altogether too eager to engage deadly animality, claiming, of course, that "It is the Will of God."

Yeah. Right.

The certainty that we are right is the surest way to go wrong. 

On Judgement Day, we will -- every one of us -- throw ourselves on "the mercy of the court."

How could it be otherwise?

We have it on high authority that whores and tax collectors will enter heaven before all the "good people" who study the law and discuss "what is best." 

In Jesus' time, tax collectors were viewed as traitors and thieves, employed by the Roman occupying army to extract revenue from devout Jews - money that would be used to finance the occupation and, eventually, the destruction of The Temple, a building immeasurably more important to the Jews than The Twin Towers were to us. http://www.allaboutjesuschrist.org/tax-collector-faq.htm 

Pax-Shalom-Salaam

Alan










No comments:

Post a Comment