Pages

Sunday, September 30, 2018

Opposition To Pope Francis Is Not Over Sex And Gender But His Ferocious Critique Of Capitalism

Image result for pax on both houses, pope francis
"Pope Francis Links"
Pope Francis: Quotations On Finance, Economics, Capitalism And Inequality
Pope Francis: One Of The Most Powerful Critiques Of Capitalism You Will Ever Read

Pope Francis: "This Economy Kills"

http://paxonbothhouses.blogspot.com/2015/01/pope-francis-this-economy-kills.html

Catholic Social Teaching

http://paxonbothhouses.blogspot.com/2015/01/catholic-social-teaching.html

Pope Francis: Moving The Moral Compass 
From "The Individual" Toward "The Collective"
http://paxonbothhouses.blogspot.com/2015/01/pope-francis-moving-moral-judgment-from.html

Pope Francis Takes On The Catholic Bureaucracy

http://paxonbothhouses.blogspot.com/2014/12/pope-francis-takes-on-catholic.html

Pro-Science Pontiff: Pope Francis On Climate Change, Evolution And The Big Bang

Pope Francis: What Christianity Looks Like When Believers Realize "God Is Love"


Related image

Martha Hennessy just sent me this column that examines the growing anti-Pope Francis sentiments in the U.S. Suggested reading ... Peace, Patrick (O'Neill), Co-operator of "The Father Charlie Mulholland Catholic Worker House," Garner, North Carolina

Pope Francis and the Battle Over Cultural Terrain

“… [W]e should not be fooled: Much of the organized opposition to Francis has nothing to do with how we care for the divorced and remarried. It is this, his trenchant critique of modern capitalism that keeps money flowing to conservative outlets intent on marginalizing what the pope says.’
— Michael Sean Winters, The National Catholic Reporter,10/29/17.
So far, we have the still unsubstantiated allegations by Archbishop Carlo Maria Viganò that Pope Francis covered up sex abuses by the now disgraced Theodore McCarrick, the Cardinal who oversaw Washington, D.C. churches from 2001-2006.  Vigano named 32 other senior clerics, all allies of Pope Francis and called for the pontiff’s resignation.
Although I remain highly skeptical of Vigano’s charges, I’m reluctant to draw any hard conclusion at this juncture. And being neither a Catholic nor a believer, I don’t have an ecclesiastical dog collar in this fight. However, my sense is that this matter is far more serious than a civil war within the Church — and that larger context warrants our attention.
Pope Francis has provoked powerful opponents who are outright bigots regarding what the pope terms “below-the-belt issues,” issues that he believes receive far too much attention by the Church. However, according to biographer Paul Vallely, it was Francis’s shift in emphasis to issues of economic justice, that was so “deeply disconcerting to those who sat comfortably atop the hierarchy of the distribution of the world’s wealth.” (P.405) In response to my written query, Villanova University Professor Massimo Faggioli, an expert on Vatican and global politics responded “This is a key issue to understanding the present moment.”
Image result for pax on both houses, pope francis
Here it’s important to note that the pope’s radical political metamorphosis preceded his ascension to the papacy.  According to Vallely, it was not until Jorge Maria Bergoglio (the future Pope Francis)  was nearing 50 years old that he fully grasped that capitalism was to blame for making and keeping people poor. And it wasn’t a Saul to Paul on the road to Damascus moment.
Bergoglio had been elected Procurate of Argentina’s Jesuits in 1987 but it was a rocky tenure and he later acknowledged making “hundreds of errors,” including a rigid and authoritarian leadership style that was offputting to his fellow Jesuits. His own journey to a profound personal change began when his superiors in Rome sent him to the Argentine city of Córdoba, a forced exile during which time he was virtually ignored by the Church hierarchy.
During this period of intense soul-searching and close interaction with ordinary people on the street, he gradually underwent an inner transformation and a radically altered political vision. He returned as an auxiliary bishop and in 1998 was named Archbishop of Buenos Aires. Bergoglio’s actions soon earned him the informal title “Bishop of the Slums” while his strong social advocacy which employed the language of Liberation Theology, earned him the intense enmity of Argentina’s most influential economic actors.
Image result for pax on both houses, pope francis
Bergoglio became Pope Francis in 2013, the first Jesuit and first non-European to be elected in over 1,200 years. From his first day in office, those who believed he’d follow in the conservative tradition of John Paul II and Benedict were quickly disabused of that notion. From washing the feet of a young female Muslim prisoner to his first visit outside Rome to the “boat people” island of Lampedusa where he expressed solidarity with illegal African economic refugees, Francis sided with the wretched of the earth. But it was his excoriating, systematic critique of global capitalism and free market fundamentalists when he linked symptoms and cause, that alarmed global economic elites:
+In his papal exhortation “Joy of the Gospels,” he wrote “We have to say ‘Thou shalt not kill’ to an economy of exclusion and inequality. Such an economy kills.”
+ He wrote that some people defend “trickle down theories which have never been confirmed by facts…and express crude and naive faith in the goodness of those wielding power.” In his home country, Francis had observed the cruel consequences of IMF policies on the most vulnerable.
+ He described an amoral, throwaway culture where the elderly are deemed “no longer useful” and the poor are “leftovers.”
+ Offshore banking, credit default swaps and derivatives were described as “proximate immorality.”
+ His encyclical, Laudatory si’: On Caring for our Common Home,” named capitalism as a primary cause of climate change and in preparing the document Francis consulted with Brazilian theologian Leonardo Boff, the leading theorist of Liberation Theology.
+ Echoing Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., the pope proclaimed that “Working for a just distribution of the fruits of the earth and human labor is not mere philanthropy. It is a moral obligation. For Christians, the responsibility is even greater. It is a commandment.”
+ Francis directly challenged Washington’s rationale for its war on terrorism by saying that because “the socioeconomic system is unjust at its root, violence and conflict are inevitable.” Further, wars in the Middle East are not about Islam but a consequence of political and economic interests where disenfranchised people turn to desperate measures. He concluded that “Capitalism is terror against all humanity.”
Image result for pax on both houses, pope francis
Given the intellectual heft of his argument, the fact of some 1.3 billion Catholics and possessing, arguably, the world’s foremost moral credentials, the pope’s political enemies were at a disadvantage in fighting ideological battles on his turf. While biding their time, as John Gehring noted in The American Prospect, major Catholic businesspersons threatened to withhold sizable financial donations to the Church. Influential Catholics and publishing outlets set out to discredit the revolutionary pope. For example, the Heritage Foundation’s Stephen Moore, a Catholic, wrote in Forbes Magazinethat Francis had “aligned himself with the far left and has embraced a philosophy that would make people poor and less free.”
To obtain a more decisive impact, the pope’s enemies needed to conjure up an issue or wait for one. Vagano’s allegations about a Vatican cover-up either fell or were deposited in their laps. If Francis could be smeared over this matter, his moral authority on matters closer to their hearts would be tarnished. And barring a definitive resolution, doubts could be sown as a default strategy.
Emblematic of these efforts is the friendship between Vagano and OPUS DEI member Timothy Busch, avright-wing, Catholic, California lawyer and businessperson. The August 27, 2018 issue of The New York Times reported that Busch advised Vagano on the letter prior to its publication. Busch also sits on the Board of Governors that own the National Catholic Register, one of the first outlets to publish Vagano’s 8,000 word, 11-page letter, entitled “Testimony.” Conservative Catholic journalists acknowledged helping to prepare, edit and distribute the letter. In the meantime, digital Catholic media hostile to Francis worked overtime to undermine him.
Image result for pax on both houses, pope francis
The contrast between Francis and Busch couldn’t be more stark. On the one hand, Francis asserts that the manner in which those who run the financial system are trained, favors the “advancement of business leaders who are capable, but greedy and unscrupulous.” On the other hand, the Catholic University of America (CUA) in Washington,  D.C, recently renamed its business school the Tim and Steph Busch School of Business after receiving a gift of $15 million from the Busch Family Foundation. Five other donors brought the total to $47 million.  Among them was the Koch Family Foundation which chipped in an additional $10 million even though Koch readily admits he’s not religious, is pro-choice and approves of same sex marriage. Busch also persuaded Art Ciocca, CEO emeritus of The Wine Group to ante up another $10 million.
In announcing his gift, Busch said it was to help “show how capitalism and Catholicism can work hand in hand” and he wrote an complementary op-ed in The Wall Street Journal entitled “Teaching Capitalism to Catholics” in which he claimed that free markets are buttressed by moral principles taught by the Catholic Church. In a speech to CUA students, as reported in the Catholic Standard, Busch noted that as the only pontifical university in the United States, “We’re the pope’s business school” and later added,  “We realized that a professor in a business school can impact 100,000 students in his or his lifetime.”  To the influential, conservative Catholic organization, Legatus: Ambassadors for Christ in the Marketplace, Busch told 160 well-heeled members that the business school’s mission is to “impact how students think.” Note: Lest anyone question his motives, Busch said “The focus of my life is getting myself into heaven and to help others get there.”
Image result for pax on both houses, pope francis
Busch, along with Fr. Robert J. Spritzer, S.J., also co-founded the Napa Institute, which promotes a mix of free-market economics and theology. Among its goals is to “continue the work of the Apostles and their successors.”  Napa hosts hundreds of wealthy Catholic philanthropists at its annual gathering where they hear lectures from conservative bishops, philosophers and theologians.  In a September 5, 2018, letter to Napa’s “constituents,” Busch denied any involvemnt in Vagano’s letter but otherwise has not responded to further requests for comment. He also encouraged “constituents” to attend Napa’s upcoming conference on how to exert lay person influence on the Vatican.
In closing, Antonio Gramsci, the twentieth-century Marxist, explained  that culture, class and politics are inextricably intertwined. Powerful groups seek to influence culture with the human mind as the target. From the outset of his papacy, Francis sought to alter this landscape by vocalizing how capitalism is the primary cause of social injustice. In doing so he became a marked man. We’re witnessing one site in the larger struggle for cultural terrain, a battle occurring on many levels, including the Catholic Church.
More articles by:
Image result for pax on both houses, pope francis
A look at the pope's opposition...

The Thinking Housewife And The Vilification Of Pope Francis by Catholic Traditionalists
More Catholic Than The Pope: The Radical Catholic Traditionalist Movement
What Catholic Traditionalists -- And Other Christian Conservatives -- "Don't Get"
"What You Need To Know About The Man Who Claims To Be Pope"
Sedevacantism

"The Thinking Housewife's Passion For Pope Paul IV Who Initiated Jewish Ghettos"
The Thinking Housewife and Closeted White Supremacy
"The United States Of Homosexual Imperialism," By Laura Wood, "The Thinking Housewife"
The Thinking Housewife: Marriage, Divorce And Absolutism
"Totalitarian Absolutism And The Thinking Housewife"
http://paxonbothhouses.blogspot.com/2014/09/totalitarian-absolutism-and-thinking.htmlhttp://paxonbothhouses.blogspot.com/2018/07/this-weapon-shot-down-catholic.html"
This Weapon Shot Down Papal Infallibility
Laura Wood, "The Thinking Housewife," On "Bergolio's Ideology"
"The Thinking Housewife" Slags Pope Francis As "Sloganeering Papal Impostor"

Liberalism: "Satanic Rebellion Against God?" (The Thinking Housewife)

"The Thinking Housewife," Laura Wood: An Interview With Pope Francis
http://paxonbothhouses.blogspot.com/2013/10/the-thinking-housewife-laura-wood.html

My Correspondence With A Christian Fundamentalist: "The Best... Becomes Evil"

"The Politics Of Horror In Conservative Evangelicalism," '09 Outstanding Academic Title"
http://paxonbothhouses.blogspot.com/2014/11/the-politics-of-horror-in-conservative.html


In 2016 Kavanaugh Said Lie Detectors Were "An Important Law Enforcement Tool." Now?

In 2016, Kavanaugh Said Lie Detectors Were "An Important Law Enforcement Tool." Now there's not a snow ball's chance in hell he would EVER a | made w/ Imgflip meme maker
In 2016 Kavanaugh Said Lie Detectors Were "An Important Law Enforcement Tool." 
Now there's not a snow ball's chance in hell he would EVER agree to a polygraph.
Why is that?

Professor Christine Blasey Ford Took A Lie Detector Test. She Passed. Would Brett Kavanaugh? | made w/ Imgflip meme maker



Kavanaugh Threatens To Further Erode Support For Republicans Already Struggling In Suburbia

Unlike Blasey Ford, Kavanaugh Has Every "Reason" To Lie. If He Acknowledged Sexual Assault, His Whole Life Would Fall Apart. | made w/ Imgflip meme maker
Partisan rage over Kavanaugh accusations roils midterm campaigns
The emotional battle over sexual assault allegations against Supreme Court nominee Brett M. Kavanaugh threatens to further erode support for House Republicans already struggling to survive in centrist suburban districts, while in Senate races it is giving GOP challengers in pro-Trump states a chance to inspire previously unenthusiastic conservatives.
By Amy Gardner and Mike DeBonis  •  Read more »

"Blasey Ford's Testimony Is A Disaster For The Republican Party" Fox News Anchor Chris Wallace | made w/ Imgflip meme maker


White Evangelical? Jesus Would Like A Word With You.

48% Of White Evangelicals Want Kavanaugh's Confirmation Even If He's Guilty | made w/ Imgflip meme maker

48% Of White Evangelicals Want Kavanaugh's Confirmation Even If He's Guilty


48% Of White Evangelicals Want Kavanaugh's Confirmation Even If He's Guilty | made w/ Imgflip meme maker

48% Of White Evangelicals Want Kavanaugh's Confirmation Even If He's Guilty


48% Of White Evangelicals Want Kavanaugh's Confirmation Even If He's Guilty | made w/ Imgflip meme maker

48% Of White Evangelicals Want Kavanaugh's Confirmation Even If He's Guilty


48% Of White Evangelicals Want Kavanaugh's Confirmation Even If He's Guilty | made w/ Imgflip meme maker

48% Of White Evangelicals Want Kavanaugh's Confirmation Even If He's Guilty


48% Of White Evangelicals Want Kavanaugh's Confirmation Even If He's Guilty | made w/ Imgflip meme maker

48% Of White Evangelicals Want Kavanaugh's Confirmation Even If He's Guilty






"Republicans Can Dump Kavanaugh Now, Or Risk A Nightmare Scenario"

There Are So Many Ways Kavanaugh's Past Can Blow Up On Him  - From Felony Perjury Charges To Sexual Misconduct In Maryland Where There Is No | made w/ Imgflip meme maker
Alan: It is possible the GOP has already decided to dump Kavanaugh and that the new FBI investigation (so oddly embraced by the Republican establishment) is to generate evidence, whether flimsy or fulsome, to justify K's ouster.

"Republicans Can Dump Kavanaugh Now, 
Or Risk A Nightmare Scenario"



Exchange With Frog Hospital's Fred Owens Concerning Kavanaugh's Anger And Blasey Ford's Strength

In His Supreme Court Confirmation Hearing, Kavanaugh Ranted About "Revenge On Behalf Of The Clintons." Such Talk Is Ungrounded Conspiratoria | made w/ Imgflip meme maker
Fred Owens Blasey carried the day because she spoke forcefully and without rancor, whereas Kavanough made a fool of himself .... his anger won no converts, so let him rant.

Alan: I agree with your assessment of Dr. Blasey Ford and Judge Kavanaugh.

In public presentation, "cool" is advisable and anger is not.


However, I venture that Dr. Blasey Ford would not have gotten her "day in court" if rage had not motivated her in the beginning.


Let's not throw out the baby with the bath.

It is also a safe bet that the expression of fury by the two women confronting Jeff Flake on the elevator was essential to the Arizona senator's course reversal.


Needless to say, it is impossible to predict where the FBI investigation will lead, but it is good that it's taking place.


"Everybody's grumpy uncle" Bernie Sanders has this to say:

http://paxonbothhouses.blogspot.com/2018/09/bernie-sanders-fbi-must-determine-if.html

48% Of White Evangelicals Want Kavanaugh Confirmed Even If He's Guilty. | made w/ Imgflip meme maker


Bernie Sanders: The FBI Must Determine If Kavanaugh Told The Truth Under Oath

An Honored Legal Principle Declares: "Falsus In Uno, Falsus In Omnibus" "False In One Thing, False In Everything" | made w/ Imgflip meme maker
Bernie Sanders: FBI Must Determine If Kavanaugh Told The Truth Under Oath
https://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/sanders-wants-fbi-to-determine-if-kavanaugh-told-the-truth-under-oath_us_5baff444e4b0c7575965a236

Lying to Congress is a federal crime.

The FBI must examine the veracity of Kavanaugh’s statements under oath in addition to the sexual assault allegations against him. Kavanaugh's truthfulness with the Senate goes to the very heart of whether he should be confirmed to the court.

NPR Probes The White House-Controlled Sham Kavanaugh Investigation

Long-Time Kavanaugh Supporter: "I Know Brett, But I Wouldn’t Confirm Him," The Atlantic

Starting in 2004, Five Times Brett Kavanaugh Appears To Have Lied To Congress While Under Oath

http://paxonbothhouses.blogspot.com/2018/09/starting-in-2004-five-times-brett.html

Kavanaugh Said, Under Oath, That He Had No Connections To Yale When In Fact He Was A Legacy Student 
Newsweek

Feinstein Uncovers Another Lie

In 2016 Kavanaugh Said Lie Detectors Were "An Important Law Enforcement Tool." Now?

The Borowitz Report: "Nation’s Criminals Ask for F.B.I. Investigation Kavanaugh Just Got"

Stanford Psychology Professor Christine Blasey Ford Alleges Sexual Assault By Kavanaugh

"A List of Everyone the FBI Could Interview About Brett Kavanaugh if They Really Want The Truth"

Brett Kavanaugh Is A Liar


Kavanaugh's Judicial Temperament "This whole two-week effort has been a calculated and orchestrated political hit, fueled (by) revenge on be | made w/ Imgflip meme maker
For Kavanaugh to say he has been the victim of a calculated and orchestrated political hit "fueled by revenge on behalf of the Clintons" is a bald faced lie under oath.

48% Of White Evangelicals Want Kavanaugh Confirmed Even If He's Guilty. | made w/ Imgflip meme maker

Image result for kavanaugh beer drinking cartoons





Starting In 2004, 5 Times Brett Kavanaugh Appears To Have Lied To Congress While Under Oath

Kavanaugh's Judicial Temperament "This whole two-week effort has been a calculated and orchestrated political hit, fueled (by) revenge on be | made w/ Imgflip meme maker
For Kavanaugh to say he has been the victim of a calculated and orchestrated political hit "fueled by revenge on behalf of the Clintons" is a bald faced lie under oath.

Five Times Brett Kavanaugh Appears To Have Lied To Congress While Under Oath
Pesky documents keep surfacing to contradict the nominee's claims about his past

We Know Kavanaugh Loves Beer And Was Often Pukingly Drunk. How Would He Know If He Blacked Out? | made w/ Imgflip meme maker